Should I Play Jonathan Taylor?
Imagine you’re on the edge of your seat, deciding whether to draft or start Jonathan Taylor in your fantasy football lineup. The question, "Should I play Jonathan Taylor?" is more than just a choice; it’s a strategic move that could define your fantasy season. Here, we delve into what might influence your decision.

Jonathan Taylor, as one of the NFL’s leading running backs, presents a compelling case for inclusion in any fantasy team. His performance over the last season, where he not only led in rushing yards but also became a significant red-zone threat, showcases his potential. His speed, agility, and the ability to break tackles make him a fantastic choice for any fantasy manager. However, the decision isn’t as straightforward as one might think.
Consider the Matchup
Every decision in fantasy football begins with the matchup. Is Taylor up against a formidable defensive line that consistently ranks high in preventing rushing yards? Or does he face a team with a weaker run defense, providing him an opportunity to shine? Analyzing recent performances of the opposing defenses can give you a clearer picture. For instance, if the Indianapolis Colts are pitted against a team like the Buffalo Bills, known for their robust run defense, you might want to think twice.
Injury Reports
Another critical aspect to ponder is health. With running backs, the wear and tear over a season can lead to injuries. While Taylor is known for his resilience, no player is impervious to injuries. Keeping an eye on the weekly injury reports or any signs of him being less than 100% could tilt the scales. An injured or not fully recovered Taylor might not deliver the stats you need.
Utilization
How the coach plans to utilize Taylor in the game plan can greatly affect his fantasy output. If the game flow requires the Colts to pass more or if the coaching staff decides to split carries among several backs, Taylor’s fantasy value could decrease. On the flip side, if all signs point towards a run-heavy approach, perhaps driven by the opponent’s weaknesses or game strategy, then Taylor could have a monster game.
Strength of Schedule

Looking ahead, the Colts’ schedule strength plays a pivotal role. A string of favorable matchups could make Taylor a consistent high scorer. However, if the road ahead is dotted with tough defenses, you might want to look elsewhere for weekly stars. Evaluating the upcoming games not only helps in starting decisions but also in planning trades or pickups.
Current Form
Lastly, consider Taylor’s recent games. Has he been underperforming due to various reasons like recovering from an injury, poor offensive line play, or perhaps the weather has impacted games? Current form is often a good indicator of future performance. If Taylor has been on a hot streak, doubling down on him might make sense, given his potential to carry teams.
In light of these factors, if Taylor has a good matchup, is healthy, and the game plan favors his style of play, then the choice becomes more straightforward. However, if these elements suggest caution, you might opt for a safer pick or diversify your lineup.
The Verdict
Ultimately, choosing whether to play Jonathan Taylor boils down to risk vs. reward. His sheer talent means he carries a high ceiling alongside a lower floor if conditions aren’t favorable. Fantasy football thrives on such decision-making, where you weigh probabilities, trust your instincts, and assess the tangible variables at play. If all signs align, starting Taylor could be a game-changer for your team’s success. If not, having a backup plan or a bench option ready might save your squad from a setback.
The beauty of fantasy football lies in these strategic choices. They not only make the game exciting but also deeply personal as each decision reflects your understanding, intuition, and sometimes, your belief in a player’s capabilities. So, when you’re pondering, "Should I play Jonathan Taylor?" remember, it’s your team, your call, and each game week presents a new opportunity. Make it count.